Based on recent guest experiences, several top-rated accommodations stand out on Harbour Island, each offering its own charm and level of service. Whether you're looking for a boutique beachfront escape or an elegant resort with full amenities, the island has something to match your travel style.
According to Google Hotels Harbour Island, The Dunmore remains one of the most celebrated options. Set along the iconic Pink Sands Beach, it features oceanfront cottages, lush landscaping, and a relaxed yet sophisticated ambiance. Reviewers consistently praise its beachfront location and hospitality, although some mention that certain rooms may not feel fully updated given the price point.
Another well-regarded property listed on Google Hotels Harbour Island is Coral Sands Hotel. It blends laid-back Caribbean charm with modern comfort, offering beachside rooms, a pool, two restaurants, and exceptional service. Guests appreciate the resort’s direct access to the beach and its welcoming atmosphere, though peak-season service may occasionally feel slow.
Valentines Resort & Marina also earns high marks, especially from families and boaters. With spacious villas, an on-site marina, and access to dining and spa services, it’s centrally located and often recommended in the Harbour Island Guide for travelers seeking convenience without sacrificing quality. The resort's poolside bar and walkable location are consistent highlights.
Another trusted name in the Harbour Island Guide is Pink Sands Resort, nestled across 20 lush acres. This resort offers private cottages and a peaceful, romantic setting perfect for couples. Guests often comment on the excellent dining and natural beauty surrounding the property, making it a top pick for serenity and seclusion.
For those traveling in large groups or seeking an ultra-private experience, La Palmeraie Villas offers something completely different. Though not a traditional hotel, this luxury estate includes two lavish beachfront mansions—the Modern House and the Asian House—each with nine bedrooms, private pools, rooftop decks, and full-time staff including chefs and butlers. It’s ideal for high-end travelers looking for exclusivity, privacy, and the feel of a private resort.
