When planning your stay, browsing Trip Advisor Hotels Harbour Island gives travelers a trusted look into guest experiences. The following hotels are consistently ranked among the top places to stay, offering a blend of luxury, charm, and personalized service. From beachfront resorts to intimate boutique inns, each one brings something unique to the island.
Coral Sands Hotel
With a 4.2/5 rating from over 611 reviewers, Coral Sands Hotel is a favorite among those seeking a refined yet relaxed beach experience. Located directly on Pink Sands Beach, the hotel features ocean-view suites, a heated pool, beachside dining, and a stylish interior with a tropical flair. Guests frequently highlight the attentive service and peaceful setting, making it ideal for couples and families alike.
Pink Sands Resort
With a 4.2/5 rating from over 524 reviewers, Pink Sands Resort is praised for its tranquil, upscale feel and lush setting across 20 acres. The resort’s private pastel-colored cottages are tucked into flowering gardens with direct beach paths, offering the perfect escape for honeymooners or anyone craving seclusion. Dining at the beachfront Blue Bar is often mentioned as a highlight in Trip Advisor Hotels Harbour Island reviews.
Rock House Hotel
With a 4.8/5 rating from over 375 reviewers, Rock House Hotel is known for its unique style and location in Dunmore Town. Originally a private residence, the hotel features bold decor, a cliffside pool, and candlelit terrace dining. Guests consistently praise the personalized service, quiet atmosphere, and artistic aesthetic that sets it apart from larger resorts.
Valentines Resort & Marina
With a 4.3/5 rating from over 439 reviewers, Valentines Resort combines resort amenities with marina access, making it a top pick for yachters and families. Guests appreciate the full-service spa, dive center, poolside bar, and spacious villas. As noted in the Guide of Harbour Island, it’s one of the most versatile stays on the island, balancing upscale comfort with a central location.
The Dunmore Hotel & Resort
With a 4.6/5 rating from over 243 reviewers, The Dunmore is a standout for those who value privacy, ocean views, and classic Bahamian elegance. The resort’s cottages feature custom decor, while the beachfront restaurant and bar deliver high-end service in a laid-back setting. Many travelers return year after year for the welcoming staff and peaceful environment.
The Landing Hotel
With a 4.2/5 rating from over 145 reviewers, The Landing blends historic charm with a modern boutique feel. Set in a 19th-century property, it offers individually styled rooms and one of the island’s best restaurants. Wine lovers and culinary travelers are especially drawn to the intimate setting and curated menu, making it a standout in the Guide of Harbour Island.
Tingum Village Hotel
With a 4.4/5 rating from over 126 reviewers, Tingum Village is an affordable, cozy choice just a few minutes from Pink Sands Beach. Rooms feature Caribbean-inspired decor, and guests often note the warm hospitality of the family-run team. The on-site bar and grill serves local fare, and the laid-back setting appeals to travelers looking for an authentic and unpretentious experience.
If you’re deciding where to stay, these properties represent the best-reviewed accommodations according to Trip Advisor reviews for hotels in Harbour Island listings. Whether you prefer luxury, charm, or budget-conscious comfort, the Guide of Harbour Island ensures you'll find the right fit for your trip.
