If you're planning a trip and want to know the best way to get to Harbour Island, traveler reviews make one option stand out above the rest. The most seamless and widely recommended route is to fly into North Eleuthera Airport (ELH), which receives direct flights from major U.S. cities like Miami, Charlotte, Atlanta, and Fort Lauderdale. From there, it's a short taxi ride—typically about $5 and 10 minutes—to the dock. A quick water taxi, costing another $5 to $10 per person, brings you directly to the island in just a few more minutes. It’s often described as a hassle-free and scenic transfer that captures the start of the island charm.

Reviewers agree that this route offers both ease and reliability, especially for those coming from the U.S. mainland. It combines air, land, and sea in a way that feels adventurous but not overly complicated. Many repeat visitors mention that this layered journey becomes part of the experience itself and is often what they recommend to anyone asking how to reach Harbour Island efficiently.

For those already in Nassau or planning to stay there first, the ferry is another option. Bahamas Ferries offers service from Nassau to Harbour Island via Spanish Wells, with a total travel time of just under three hours. However, these ferries usually run Friday through Sunday, making scheduling more restrictive. This method may suit travelers seeking a scenic, water-focused journey but is less ideal for those prioritizing speed or flexibility.

Chartering a private seaplane or yacht is also possible for visitors seeking a luxurious, direct transfer. Seaplane services like Tropic Ocean Airways can land right at the island’s Valentine’s Marina, eliminating the need for additional land or ferry connections. Private boat options from nearby islands offer a boutique experience that’s perfect for celebratory trips or larger groups looking to visit in style.

While all these routes offer their own appeal, the overwhelming consensus from travel forums and frequent guests is that flying into ELH and then hopping onto the water taxi strikes the perfect balance of convenience, cost, and charm. This method is reliable year-round, and the smooth transition from plane to taxi to boat creates a memorable arrival that sets the tone for your stay.

For anyone looking to visit Harbour Island soon, especially first-timers, this route is the most praised and straightforward option. It's not just about reaching the destination—it's about starting the adventure the moment you land.