When planning a dream getaway to Harbour Island, selecting the right vacation rental can elevate the entire experience. According to recent reviews from platforms like Vrbo, Airbnb, TripAdvisor, and RentByOwner, several standout properties consistently impress guests with their amenities, service, and unbeatable locations.
Among the most acclaimed is Rosalita House, a six-bedroom beachfront estate perched above the ocean with breathtaking views and top-tier service. Guests have praised its privacy, full staff (including chef, concierge, and housekeeping), and amenities like a private gym, lush gardens, and infinity pool. It’s a preferred choice among celebrities and discerning travelers, making it one of the most popular rentals Harbour Island has to offer.
Equally prominent are the La Palmeraie Villas, comprising the Asian House and Modern House. These side-by-side oceanfront mansions offer nine bedrooms each, rooftop jacuzzis, Olympic-sized pools, private chefs, and a full concierge team. With direct access to Pink Sands Beach and unmatched luxury, they set the gold standard for group or family stays.
Smaller but just as beloved is The Mill Apartment, a centrally located, recently renovated three-bedroom unit in Dunmore Town. It boasts a 4.97/5 rating from nearly 60 guests, who consistently applaud its stylish design, bay views, and walking-distance convenience to shops and restaurants.
Also topping guest favorites is Bamboo House, a tropical four-bedroom retreat with a private pool and lush garden surroundings. It combines serene ambiance with proximity to the heart of town, making it perfect for both relaxation and exploration. Rentals like this are often recommended in any quality guide of Harbour Island thanks to their unique blend of charm and practicality.
Historic charm meets modern comfort in Salt Box, a beautifully restored home that sleeps up to 10 guests and features a private pool. Reviewers love the attention to detail and peaceful location.
Other highly rated options include Casa DeDe, a spacious ocean-view Bahamian home known for its breezy layout and welcoming feel, and Sea Star, a luxury beachfront compound that offers both privacy and beach access within a few steps.
Touchstone’s House stands out for its one-acre beachfront location and strong reputation among travelers, while Kelly Krest is a favorite for couples and small families thanks to its cozy setup and perfect placement on Pink Sands Beach.
For those seeking upscale group accommodations, Crown Affair features a 40-foot pool, beautiful sunset views, and expansive spaces ideal for entertaining and relaxing.
These homes represent the very best of Harbour Island hospitality. Whether you're visiting for a romantic escape, a family reunion, or a luxury getaway, these properties have earned their place among the top-rated and most popular rentals Harbour Island offers today. By following any reputable guide of Harbour Island, you'll likely find these names recommended time and again—proof of their consistent excellence.
