When exploring the Best Bakeries Harbour Island, two stand out for their freshness, reputation, and unique offerings. Arthur’s Bakery is a beloved local institution located at the corner of Crown and Dunmore Streets in Dunmore Town. Open Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m., Arthur’s serves fresh-baked cinnamon buns, donuts, muffins, coconut bread, and rum cake. It also doubles as a breakfast café with banana pancakes and lobster scrambled eggs. Guests appreciate the cozy garden seating, friendly service, and consistent quality—arriving early is advised, as popular items sell out quickly. Many travelers discover Arthur’s through word-of-mouth or trusted listings in the Harbour Island Guide, and it remains one of the island’s most recommended morning stops.
Bluwatur Bakery, a newer but fast-rising name among the Best Bakeries Harbour Island, delivers fresh artisan goods Friday through Monday. Open from 7:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m., Bluwatur focuses on sourdough boules, sticky pecan buns, and celebration cakes using seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. Their passionfruit coconut and carrot cakes have developed a loyal following, and advance pre-orders—recommended at least a week in advance—are essential if you want something specific. This bakery doesn’t have a walk-in storefront but operates as a pre-order and pick-up concept, which many consider a hidden gem mentioned in some versions of the Harbour Island Guide.
Whether you’re drawn to the charm of Arthur’s or the boutique flavors of Bluwatur, both deliver memorable experiences. From flaky pastries to custom cakes, these two bakeries continue to shape the sweet side of Harbour Island life.
