Based on recent reviews and rankings, some of the best cafés on the island consistently appear at the top of TripAdvisor Coffee Harbour Island lists, offering visitors a perfect mix of strong brews, delicious breakfasts, and relaxing atmospheres. These favorites aren’t just about the coffee—they’re beloved for their character, views, and local charm.

Bahamas Coffee Roasters is often highlighted as a must-visit in the TripAdvisor Coffee Harbour Island category. With a 4.6-star average from over 200 reviews, it wins praise for its rich espresso, breakfast burritos, and friendly staff that give it a welcoming neighborhood feel. Tourists rave about how it becomes their go-to each morning, offering both dine-in and grab-and-go options.

Another standout is Cocoa Coffee House, a waterfront café located next to Valentine’s Marina. Reviewers frequently mention its cozy, stylish vibe and consistent quality—perfect for a post-beach coffee or early-morning smoothie. The iced lattes and acai bowls are particular crowd-pleasers, with many travelers visiting multiple times during their stay.

Arthur’s Bakery also earns a strong reputation thanks to its combination of hearty breakfast favorites and laid-back outdoor seating. Whether you're after banana pancakes, cinnamon buns, or simply a strong cup of coffee in a charming garden nook, Arthur’s fits the bill for comfort and flavor.

For a modern health-conscious twist, Sweet Spot Café gets top marks for plant-based drinks and bowls. It has the highest average rating of all, praised for its creativity and refreshing approach to coffee culture.

If you're using any reliable Harbour Island Guide, these four spots are guaranteed to be mentioned. Locals and visitors alike appreciate how each offers something different—from traditional coffeehouse energy to wellness-focused blends and island-inspired breakfasts. And according to every major Harbour Island Guide, the café scene here is one of the island's most pleasant surprises, making mornings a highlight of the trip.