Captain Bob’s Seafood and Meat Market has been operating on Harbour Island for over 20 years. The business started primarily as a seafood and meat market serving the island community and has since expanded to include general groceries, making it one of the island’s two main food shopping destinations. It is also the best Harbour Island food store and also the most expensive.

Location & Contact:

• Address: Bay Street , Dunmore Town, Harbour Island
• Phone: 242-333-3628 (main) / 242-359-7725 (cell)
• Email: captainbobsmarketplace@gmail.com
• Hours:
  • Monday-Saturday: 8:30 AM – 6:00 PM
  • Sunday: 8:30 AM – 1:00 PM
  • Store Size: While exact square footage is not documented in available sources, Captain Bob’s is described as one of the “two main food shops” on Harbour Island and appears to be comparable in size to Piggly Wiggly, meaning it’s a small neighborhood market rather than a large supermarket, it likely ranges between 2,000-3,000 square feet.

Type of Foods & Products Offered:

Meat & Seafood :

• Fresh seafood: lobster, conch, various types of fish
• Top quality beef
• Chicken
• Lamb
• Specialty game meats
• Pork

Gourmet & Specialty Items:

• Specialty cheeses (multiple selections)
• Truffle honey
• Quince paste
• Fig spread
• Gourmet crackers
• Imported deli items

General Groceries:

• Fresh produce (delivered weekly)
• Pantry staples
• Frozen foods
• Ice cold frozen treats
• General household items
• Items suitable for beach picnics and private events

Weekly Shipping Schedule: Like all Harbour Island stores, fresh produce is delivered weekly by boat from Nassau and the United States. The exact day isn’t specified in sources, but typically mid-week. Captain Bob’s advertises that “new products arrive all the time,” suggesting they may receive multiple shipments or have priority access to fresh deliveries given their reputation and specialty focus.

Pricing: Captain Bob’s is consistently described as “way more expensive” than Piggly Wiggly . While both stores charge 30-50% above mainland U.S. prices due to import duties and shipping, Captain Bob’s commands premium pricing because of:

• Higher quality products
• Specialty and gourmet items
• Fresh meat and seafood (not available at Piggly Wiggly)
• Curated selection vs. basic staples

Visitors specifically note that Captain Bob’s offers “more refined foods” which justifies the higher price point for those seeking quality over economy.

Difference in Food Quality Compared to Other Harbour Island Stores:

Captain Bob’s stands out as:

• The only source for fresh meat – All other stores on the island only carry frozen meats, if any
• The only source for fresh seafood – While fishermen sell at the docks, Captain Bob’s is the reliable retail source
• The specialty/gourmet destination – Items like truffle honey, artisan cheeses, and specialty items aren’t available elsewhere except perhaps Dunmore Deli (which is smaller and more limited)
• Higher consistency – 20+ years of operation has established quality standards and reliable supply chains

Customer Reputation & Reviews: While specific online reviews are limited, visitor recommendations consistently identify Captain Bob’s as:

• “The better spot” compared to Piggly Wiggly
• “A good small grocery store” located conveniently for many properties
• The preferred option for visitors who want to cook quality meals
• Essential for stocking vacation rentals when fresh proteins are needed
• The go-to for upscale entertaining (cheese platters, private events)

Notable Services:

• Pre-ordering available: Visitors can email a provisions list before arrival
• Delivery arrangements: Can be made by calling or emailing
• Yacht provisioning: Specifically markets to marina and yacht customers
• Custom orders: Can arrange for specific items with advance notice

Strategic Position: Captain Bob’s occupies a unique niche as Harbour Island’s premium food purveyor, bridging the gap between basic grocery stores and the high-end dining experiences island visitors expect. For vacation rental guests who want to prepare quality meals, entertain with cheese and wine, or simply have access to fresh proteins, Captain Bob’s is essentially the only viable option, which allows them to command premium pricing while maintaining a loyal customer base among repeat visitors and upscale clientele.