Pigly Wigly store is probably the most popular grocery store on the island, thanks to its central location that makes it the closest option from all hotels and vacation rentals, sitting at approximately a 4-minute golf cart drive from most accommodations in Dunmore Town. The store is compact but manages to stock the essentials that both locals and tourists need during their island stays.

It is the less expensive option compared to Captain Bob’s Marketplace when it comes to Grocery shopping in Harbour Island, but visitors should understand that “less expensive” is still very expensive by mainland standards.

The store operates under the charming philosophy expressed by its owner’s well-known motto: “If we do not have it, you do not need it,” which perfectly captures the practical, make-do spirit of island provisioning where flexibility and creativity become essential parts of the shopping experience.

Location & Contact:

• Address: King & Crown Street, Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
• Phone: 242-333-2120

Store Description:

Pigly Wigly is one of the two largest grocery stores on Harbour Island, though “largest” is relative on this tiny island. The store measures approximately 2,000 square feet, which visitors consistently describe as “only a small room” or a “small convenience store” rather than anything resembling a mainland supermarket. Despite its compact size, Pigly Wigly serves as a staple for the island community and is centrally located in Dunmore Town, making it easily accessible by golf cart from most hotels and vacation rentals.

Foods & Products Offered:

• General groceries covering basic needs
• Household items and essentials
• Pet supplies
• Toys
• Over-the-counter (OTC) drugs and medications
• Pantry staples
• Snacks and beverages
• Limited selection of canned and packaged goods
• No fresh meat counter
• No fresh fish section
• Limited fresh produce (whatever has arrived on the weekly boat shipment)

Operating Hours: Based on available information, hours appear to be:

• Monday to Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM (some sources indicate 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM)
• Saturday: Limited hours
• Sunday: Reduced hours or possibly closed Note: Hours may vary seasonally or during holidays, and island businesses don’t always maintain rigid schedules

Shipping Schedule:

Food and groceries arrive on Harbour Island from Nassau and the United States once per week, sometimes twice weekly during busy holiday periods (Christmas, Easter, Spring Break). The shipments arrive by boat, typically mid-week. If visitors arrive just after a shipment, shelves are relatively well-stocked, but if timing is off, certain items may be out of stock for days until the next delivery arrives. Fresh produce quality depends on shipping time and conditions, with items sometimes arriving less fresh than mainland standards.

Delivery Service:

Pigly Wigly itself does not appear to offer direct delivery service.

Pricing:

Prices at Pigly Wigly are 30% to 50% higher than mainland U.S. prices due to:

• Import duties on all goods entering the Bahamas
• Shipping costs to reach the remote island
• Limited competition (only a handful of stores)
• Small-scale operations without bulk purchasing power
• Profit margins reflecting the captive market

Pigly Wigly is generally considered the more affordable option for basic groceries, though still expensive by mainland standards. Customer reviews consistently mention that while prices are high, this is expected on the island and accepted as part of the experience.

Customer Reviews & Reputation:

Based on visitor feedback across multiple platforms

Positive comments:

• Convenient location in central Dunmore Town
• Carries the basics needed for vacation provisioning
• Good for “quick market items” when you need something immediately
• Part of the authentic island shopping experience
• Friendly staff familiar with locals and repeat visitors
• Steadily improving selection over the years

Negative/realistic comments:

• Very small space with limited selection
• “Only a small room” – not a proper grocery store by mainland standards
• High prices (but expected on the island)
• Limited fresh produce and meat options
• Can be out of stock on basic items depending on shipping schedule
• No specialty or gourmet items
• Not suitable for complete vacation provisioning