Among the most affordable home rental Harbour Island options available, Sugar Apple Harbour Island presents a cozy studio apartment that delivers authentic island living just a short stroll from the world-famous Pink Sands Beach. This charming home rental Harbour Island property, located in the heart of Dunmore Town on Colebrooke Street, offers guests an exceptional blend of convenience, affordability, and genuine Bahamian hospitality.
Sugar Apple Harbour Island stands as a prime example of budget-conscious accommodation featuring a fully-equipped kitchenette, private bathroom, and access to a beautiful tropical garden with wooden deck and pergola.
With nightly rates ranging from $179 to $300, this property offers an accessible entry point to Harbour Island.
Miss Rosie (Rosita), who has earned widespread praise for her attentive service, local knowledge, and genuine care for guest experiences.
The property is positioned across from Ramora Bay, providing easy access to the bay side of the island. The studio sits in the heart of historic Dunmore Town, placing guests within easy walking distance of all major island amenities. The location is approximately 2 minutes to the beach and 5 minutes to the town center.
Studio Apartment
Not specified in exact square feet, described as spacious and comfortable
studio layout with double bed
2 guests (primarily designed for couples)
1 double bed
Not family-friendly for children according to property specifications
Access to quaint backyard featuring wooden deck and pergola, tropical garden, sun terrace, outdoor seating area
Part of larger property that includes multiple units
Part of a multi-unit property (The Sugar Apple Lodging consists of three ground-floor apartments with owner's residence upstairs, though the studio can be rented independently)
The nightly rental rate ranges from $179 to $300 per night, with an average rate around $287 to $326 depending on the season and booking platform. The property represents one of the most affordable accommodation options on Harbour Island, offering excellent value for budget-conscious travelers seeking proximity to Pink Sands Beach and town amenities without resort pricing.
1 night minimum stay, though this may vary based on seasonality and availability at the property manager's discretion. The flexible minimum stay policy makes this property particularly attractive for short weekend getaways or brief island visits.
Miss Rosie (Rosita) serves as owner and on-site manager, living in the upstairs apartment
Housekeeping service provided twice per week
Kitchenette fully equipped with full-size refrigerator, microwave, sink, coffee maker, toaster, and complete kitchenware for meal preparation
Beautiful tropical garden, wooden deck with pergola, sun terrace, outdoor seating area, picnic spot
Free WiFi internet access, cable television
Private bathroom with shower
Comfortable furnishings with Bahamian decorative touches
Host assists with island orientation, restaurant recommendations, activity bookings, water taxi coordination, tour arrangements including fishing and snorkeling expeditions
Washing machine and dryer available on property
Sugar Apple exemplifies traditional Bahamian apartment architecture as part of a two-story residential building built in the authentic island style. The studio apartment is located on the ground floor of the property, featuring a practical and efficient layout designed for comfortable tropical living. The architecture emphasizes indoor-outdoor connectivity, with the studio providing access to the surrounding garden and outdoor spaces that are integral to the island living experience.
The studio layout combines sleeping, living, and kitchen areas in an open plan.
French doors or large windows open onto outdoor spaces, allowing guests to extend their living area into the garden and deck areas.
The wooden deck and pergola structure in the backyard provides shaded outdoor living space ideal for the tropical climate.
The property has undergone periodic updates and refurbishments to maintain its condition and comfort.
The property is consistently described in reviews as clean and well-maintained, suggesting ongoing care and upkeep. Some reviews note that this is a basic, no-frills accommodation that prioritizes cleanliness and functionality over luxury finishes. The property presents itself as a standard, local lodging option rather than a high-end renovated space, which aligns with its affordable pricing strategy.
Sugar Apple features comfortable, practical decor with distinctive Bahamian touches that reflect the island's cultural heritage and the owner's international travel experiences. The interior is described as cozy and welcoming, creating a home-like atmosphere rather than a sterile hotel environment.
The space is elegantly decorated despite its modest size, with attention paid to creating a pleasant visual environment.
Guest rooms feature comfortable bedding with quality linens and fresh towels that are replenished regularly View: Sugar Apple offers tropical garden views and bay proximity:
Total Number of Reviews: Approximately 80-100 reviews across all platforms
Search Date: January 02, 2026
Guest reviews consistently highlight exceptional, personalized service from owner and manager Miss Rosie (Rosita) as the defining characteristic of the Sugar Apple experience.
Rosita receives extraordinary praise across virtually all reviews, with guests describing her as "a gem," "extremely nice and helpful," "incredibly kind and accommodating," "the hostess with the mostest," "a ray of sunshine," and "an angel." Multiple reviewers specifically state that Rosita is "the main reason" they chose the property and the best part of their stay.
Some reviews do note occasional challenges with utilities like water pressure, hot water, and WiFi, which appear to be related to island-wide infrastructure issues rather than property-specific problems.
Value of the Stay: Sugar Apple delivers outstanding value for travelers seeking an authentic, affordable Harbour Island experience without sacrificing location or service quality.
Listing: vrbo.com
Note: Direct phone number and email are not publicly listed but detailed contact information is provided through booking platforms. The property manager (Miss Rosie/Rosita) provides her contact number directly to guests after booking and maintains responsive communication throughout the reservation process.
Payment is accepted in cash and via PayPal. A $500 damage deposit is required 7 days before arrival and is collected via PayPal, refunded within 14 days after checkout subject to property inspection.
