Preachers Cave Harbour Island is one of the most historically rich natural landmarks in the Bahamas. Tucked into North Eleuthera, just a short journey from Dunmore Town, this open-air limestone cavern was the first place of worship for the Puritan settlers who arrived in 1648 after being shipwrecked on the Devil’s Backbone. Known as the Eleutheran Adventurers, these early settlers found shelter within the cave and held religious services there for nearly a century. The cave’s name stems from this very origin, and to this day, a large natural rock that served as their altar still rests inside, along with a commemorative plaque that marks the spiritual and historical significance of this Bahamian landmark.
The site is shaded by tall casuarina trees and laced with hanging roots and stalactites, creating an otherworldly atmosphere. Natural skylights carved into the ceiling allow light to spill in dramatically, especially in the morning hours. Beyond its historical relevance, the cave also has archaeological importance—Lucayan artifacts and remains have been found here, showing that the area was inhabited long before European settlement. It’s a place where cultural memory, geology, and spirituality intersect. If you’re using any detailed Harbour Island Excursions resource or guide, this destination is consistently highlighted as a must-see for visitors seeking more than just beach days.
Getting to Preachers Cave Harbour Island is simple. Travelers coming from Harbour Island can take a taxi or golf cart ride to the dock, followed by a short ferry ride to North Eleuthera. From there, it’s about a 25-minute drive north along Queen’s Highway. There’s a small grassy lot for parking and a short walking trail that leads directly to the cave entrance. Many pair this experience with a visit to nearby Tay Bay Beach, which is only a few minutes away on foot.
This cave isn’t commercialized or roped off—it’s free to enter, explore, and reflect. Visitors are advised to bring water, bug spray, and a flashlight if they wish to explore the deeper crevices. Whether you're captivated by the spiritual legacy of the Eleutherans or simply want a quiet, scenic escape, Preachers Cave offers something rare: a profound sense of place that leaves a lasting impression. For further reading, check out the listing on Tripadvisor.
